Listen to this article · 7 min listen

Digital health interventions for musculoskeletal (MSK) conditions love to promise big savings. For benefits strategy teams and health economists, though, the real question isn’t how big the number is, but what exactly it replaces on the books. When you understand why MSK savings are most compelling when tied to the surgical cost line, you see the true economic impact of these programs.

The Surgical Cost Line as the Anchor for MSK Program Value

Musculoskeletal conditions are a huge drain on healthcare systems, and a lot of that cost ends up in one place: expensive surgeries. So if you’re trying to figure out the ROI for an AI or digital MSK program, the real savings come from preventing or putting off those high-cost procedures. This is a classic Michael Porter argument: true value is about the health outcomes you get for every dollar you spend. With MSK, you get a much better outcome per dollar by preventing a costly surgery (while keeping the patient functional) than you do by just managing their chronic pain with less intensive, but in the end temporary, measures. Sword Health, for example, has built its entire record around hitting the surgical end of MSK treatment costs. The savings figure they publish, $3,177 per member per year, is specifically tied to their surgery avoidance program. That’s an important distinction. The savings directly hit the most expensive part of MSK care. The Sword Health Peer-Reviewed ROI Study is the benchmark for seeing what surgery avoidance actually looks like in claims data Peer-reviewed study on Sword Health surgery avoidance ROI. Focusing on the surgical cost line gives a health plan a solid, quantifiable number to judge a program’s financial performance.

Deconstructing the Recorded Savings Figure

Sword Health’s recorded savings of $3,177 per member per year is a big number, but you have to know where it comes from. That figure is a direct result of the program helping people avoid surgery. It’s not some fuzzy estimate across all MSK spending. The math is simple. A single MSK surgery is incredibly expensive once you add up the pre-operative assessments, the procedure itself, anesthesia, post-operative care, and all the rehab. A digital therapy that actually manages symptoms and improves function to the point where surgery is no longer needed generates massive cost avoidance. To be sure, Sword Health’s acquisition of Kaia for $285 million expanded its program’s reach, solidifying its spot in the movement health category. While the early savings came from surgery avoidance, this expansion shows they’re playing a longer game to address movement health more broadly, which could impact a wider range of MSK conditions and costs. Still, their whole ROI narrative is anchored in provable savings against surgical expenditures. This is completely different from “wellness” programs that can’t point to a specific, high-cost event they helped a member avoid.

Comparing Entry Points to the MSK Cost Line

In the digital MSK and chronic care space, you’ve got a few key players like Sword Health, Hinge Health, and Omada Health, and they all attack the same cost problem from different angles. We can finally compare them because they’ve all published outcome records which thankfully moves the conversation away from the funding-round hype that defined this category through 2021 and toward actual financial results. Hinge Health, for instance, leans on its care team model, using physical therapists and health coaches to walk members through digital exercise therapy and education. They’re also trying to avoid surgeries, but their path often involves a deeper, longer-term engagement with the member. Omada Health, on the other hand, uses behavioral change as its main tool, tackling chronic conditions including MSK with digital coaching and structured programs. Their approach through lifestyle and condition management can indirectly prevent things from getting bad enough to need surgery down the line. For benefits teams, the bottom line is that even though the methods are different, all these companies are trying to cut down the total MSK cost burden. The thing that makes Sword Health’s record stand out is its ability to show exactly how much it saved against the most expensive procedures, which makes the ROI calculation tangible and shows a direct financial impact. Review of digital health MSK program comparison

The Plan Economist’s Lens: Reading Recorded Outcomes

A plan economist has to look at these MSK programs with a very skeptical eye. The money these companies have raised, like Sword Health’s $453.5 million and its $4 billion valuation in June 2025, or Hinge Health’s NYSE listing in May 2025, is a sign of market confidence, but it doesn’t directly save an employer a dime. You have to stay focused on the outcome record and exactly how they calculate savings based on the procedures they claim to replace. The value of any MSK program only makes sense if the savings are tied directly to procedures that didn’t happen. Shaving 10% off physical therapy visits is one thing, but avoiding a single lumbar fusion or knee replacement provides a much bigger and more meaningful return. This is exactly where the Michael Porter framework is so useful. Michael Porter value-based healthcare framework explanation It forces you to ask: does putting money into this digital MSK program produce better health outcomes for each dollar we spend compared to the traditional path, especially when that path ends in an operating room? When a health plan is looking at a digital MSK solution, they should be asking two things: what expensive procedures is this program actually preventing, and what’s the documented financial impact? Without that direct link to the surgical cost line, any reported savings figure looks fuzzy and could even be seen as an additive cost instead of a subtractive one. The power of Sword Health’s peer-reviewed ROI, with its $3,177 in savings per member per year anchored specifically to surgery avoidance, is the kind of hard evidence that resonates with benefits strategy teams and health economists. It’s about spending smarter by preventing the most expensive procedures.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the primary driver of savings for digital MSK programs?

The primary driver of savings for digital MSK programs is their ability to mitigate or avoid high-cost surgical interventions. By preventing the need for surgery, these programs generate significant cost avoidance compared to managing chronic pain through less intensive, non-preventative measures.

How are the savings figures for digital MSK programs typically derived?

Savings figures, such as Sword Health’s $3,177 per member per year, are specifically recorded around surgery avoidance programs. This figure represents the direct impact of the program’s ability to avert surgical procedures, rather than a general reduction in overall MSK spend.

Why is focusing on the ‘surgical cost line’ important for evaluating MSK programs?

Focusing on the ‘surgical cost line’ is crucial because it provides a concrete and easily quantifiable metric for assessing the financial efficacy of MSK interventions. Preventing a costly surgery while maintaining or improving patient function represents a superior outcome per dollar spent, aligning with the outcomes per dollar spent framework.

How do different digital MSK solutions, like Sword Health, Hinge Health, and Omada Health, compare in their approach to cost savings?

While Sword Health, Hinge Health, and Omada Health all aim to reduce MSK costs, their entry points and methodologies differ. Sword Health emphasizes direct surgery avoidance, Hinge Health uses a care team approach with digital exercise therapy, and Omada Health focuses on behavioral change and lifestyle modification, which can indirectly lead to surgery avoidance.